Home About | Contact | Forum | Books | Links | Search


Index

Articles by Date

Departments

Forum
Links
Personal Liberty
Philosophy (Objectivism)
Books

Permanent Articles

Autonomist's Notebook
Basic Ideas
Bill of Rights
Humanism (critique)
Individualist Revolt
July 4 Declaration
Liberty or Death
Logical Fallacies
Medicine (critique)
Money (-Rand)
Philosophy (-Rand)
Proof
Religion (satire)
Science (critique)
Truth & Superstition
What Is Philosophy
What Is Superstition

Writers

W. James Antle III
Chuck Baldwin
Randy Barnett
Alan Caruba
Tom DeWeese
Paul Driessen
Reginald Firehammer
Lisa Fabrizio
Alfred A. Hambidge
Cass Hewitt
Scott Kauzlarich
David MacGregor
Ron Paul
Sara Pentz
Monart Pon
Burt Prelutsky
Fred Reed
Michael D. Shaw
L. Neil Smith
Barbara Stanley
G. Stolyarov II
Edward W. Younkins

The Fate of Lebanon and the Rest of Us

by Alan Caruba

On July 14 in the chamber of the United Nations Security Council, the permanent representative from Israel, Ambassador Dan Gillerman, paused to address his colleague, the ambassador from Lebanon. “You know that what we are doing is right, and if we succeed, your country will be the real beneficiary.”

 

That is the sad truth about Lebanon. What it has been unable or unwilling to do for itself, will be done by Israel when it shatters the strongholds of Hezbollah to end the rain of Iranian-made rockets on its cities. This time, Israel will withdraw to its borders, leaving Lebanon yet another opportunity to assert its sovereignty.

 

Am. Gillerman recalled a sunnier time in Lebanon’s recent history, prior to 1975 “when the Lebanese began their long descent into oppression and terror. This is a country that has been held hostage for more than 32 years by tyrants from the north and terrorists from the south.”

 

Carved out of the defeated Ottoman Empire after WWI by the French and English, Lebanon became a unique place where its large Christian population achieved a successful measure of governance in cooperation with Muslim citizens. The result was a place that was often called the Paris of the Middle East, a place that became a modern financial hub to the region.

 

With the fall of the Ottoman Empire after WWI, Lebanon became a French protectorate, while Iraq and Jordan fell under the influence of the British who also oversaw affairs in desolate area to the south called Palestine. Following WWII, Jewish refugees from the Nazi Holocaust and earlier Jewish settlers would establish Israel in 1948.

 

The “Cedar Revolution” that began on March 14, 2005 when more than a million Lebanese poured into the streets of Beirut to protest the February assassination of former Prime Minister Rafiq Hariri was brief. Anger, frustration, and desperation had overcome the fear of Syrian repression.

 

On April 26, 2005, the last of the Syrian army departed, but Hezbollah, a militant Islamic organization dedicated to the destruction of Israel, ruled southern Lebanon.

 

The Syrians had moved into Lebanon obstensively to bring an end to a 15-year civil war (1975-1990) that had been triggered by an influx of heavily armed Palestinian refugees, driven from Jordan after their failed effort to overthrow the Hashemite monarchy.

 

Reduced to its simplest terms, it was a war between Christians and Muslims. It was, however, more complex because in Lebanon, everyone is defined by their religion and this includes whether one is Roman Catholic, Greek Orthodox, Shia, Sunni, Druze or Maronite. The differences are exaggerated in the hothouse atmosphere of Islamic fantasies.

 

Israel, in effect, accepted Syrian control of Lebanon in exchange for control over Hezbollah. Yes, some rockets might hit northern Israel from time to time, but that was a small price to pay. Too many rockets put an end to that compromise. In time, Israel moved troops into the southern part of Lebanon to create a security zone. In 2000 it withdrew, having suffered too many casualties among its forces from a low-intensity warfare against them.

 

Israelis, weary from the endless attacks on their people, tried to secure peace by ceding land to the Palestinians in Gaza and promising to withdraw further from the West Bank. The Lebanese border to the north remained closely guarded against Hezbollah, a terrorist organization that had invented the suicide bomber and perfected the taking of hostages.

 

Am. Gillerman called the Cedar Revolution Lebanon’s moment of truth. Would it take the opportunity to assert its sovereignty over southern Lebanon? It did not. In fact, in the elections that followed Syria’s withdrawal, Hezbollah candidates became a part of Lebanon’s reconstituted government.

 

Lebanon remained hostage to a stateless organization that answered to both Syria and Iran.

 

Syria’s desire to reclaim Lebanon and Iran’s desire to destroy Israel forced Hezbollah to demonstrate that the millions poured into it had been a good investment. In attacks coordinated with Hamas, both terror groups kidnapped Israeli soldiers. Suddenly the heat was off Iran as concerns about its ambition to acquire nuclear weapons gave way to the attention focused on events in Lebanon and Gaza.

 

There was never any doubt of Israel’s response. Am. Gillerman told the Security Council that “Hezbollah, together with Hamas, Syria and Iran, comprise the world’s new and ominous Axis of Terror, an infamous club, the entry fee to which is the blood of innocents and the terrorizing of the entire world.”

 

“The real occupying power in Lebanon is terror—terror instigated by Hezbollah, but initiated, funded and perpetrated by Syria and Iran.”

 

If you want to see what the other nations of the Middle East will look like if there is no intervention and preemption, look at Lebanon.

 

If you want to see what Europe will look like if subjected to a similar campaign of terror, look at Lebanon.

 

The implications for the United States of America are huge. This is where we secure a large measure of the oil our economy and way of life requires. This is where we have put our troops in harm’s way to break the grip of fanatical Islam and replace it with a modern form of governance.

 

Failure is not an option, but so far U.S. diplomacy has only encouraged its enemies.

 

This is not just about tiny Israel fighting for its security and survival. This is not about restoring Lebanon to its former grandeur.

 

This is about whether Western civilization has the guts to protect itself against a tyrannical enemy.

 

 

© Alan Caruba, 2006

—(07/18/06)

[Discuss This Article.]
Alan Caruba is a widely syndicated commentator whose weekly column, "Warning Signs", is featured in The National Anxiety Center, a clearinghouse for information about "scare campaigns" designed to influence public opinion and policy. Caruba founded the Center in 1990, having been a business and science writer for many years, in addition to being a public relations counselor who has worked with many leading think tanks, corporations, and trade associations.

Alan is founding member of the National Book Critics Circle; he also posts a monthly report on new books at Bookviews. In addition, he is a longtime member of the Society of Professional Journalists, the American Society of Journalists and Authors, and the National Association of Science Writers.

A popular guest on radio and television, Caruba is available to address groups on the topics about which he writes, including environmentalism, energy, education, national security and sovereignty, property rights, and Islam. He can be reached at:


All trademarks are the sole property of their respective owners.
Copyright 2004-2005 The Autonomist & HPAmericaTM All rights reserved.